Part of the USA Today Network

View looking east on Lincoln Highway at Stony Brook, Springettsbury Township, York County, PA (Section of photo from Collection of York County History Center; Annotated by S.H. Smith, 2020)

Stony Brook Garage on the Lincoln Highway

April of 1921 featured the opening of the Stony Brook Garage by Strickler brothers Paul and Stuart along the Lincoln Highway in York County. At that time, Paul B. Strickler was 24-years old and Stuart L. Strickler was 17-years old. They were sons of Edward E. Strickler; a well to do farmer in Hellam Township.

The Stony Brook Garage is pointed out on a circa late 1920s photo; which is a view looking east on Lincoln Highway at Stony Brook in Springettsbury Township. The earliest descriptions for the garage noted it was a, “full service gas station repairing all makes of cars and specializing in automobile electrical systems.”

The Stony Brook Garage was an early Lincoln Highway business, operated by a founding owner for 53-years; from April of 1921 until December of 1974. Details are provided later in this post.

Trolley tracks are pointed out in the photo. Trolleys ran from the City of York to Wrightsville, passing through Stony Brook. Trolley service in and near the City of York existed from August 18, 1892 to February 4, 1939. However the York to Wrightsville trolley was in service for a shorter time span, from May 21, 1904 to February 1, 1933.

The whole circa late 1920s, eastward looking, photo, from the collections of the York County History Center, shows a trolley passing over Stony Run where it crosses the Lincoln Highway in Stony Brook; i.e. just east of the Locust Grove Road intersection. The trolley is on the south side of the Lincoln Highway (East Market Street) and is about to travel across the highway and head north beside, and then on, what is now Pleasant Acres Road.

View looking east–as trolley is passing over Stony Run where it crosses the Lincoln Highway in Stony Brook (Photo from Collection of York County History Center)

I’ve marked the path of the trolley on the following 1937 Penn Pilot aerial photo. The trolley photo would have been taken at a point in the extreme lower left corner of the aerial photo. The trolley would then travel the route of the green and white dashed lines to the upper right corner, on its way to Wrightsville. During the time of trolley travel, the humpback bridge on the Lincoln Highway did not exist, however a bridge did exist over the railroad tracks on what would become Pleasant Acres Road.

East of Stony Run in Stony Brook during Sept. 15, 1937 (Penn Pilot Aerial Photo; Annotations by S.H. Smith, 2014)

The Stony Brook Garage was also, unofficially, know as Strickler Brother’s Garage and then Strickler’s Garage; especially later when Stuart Strickler became the primary owner. Through the 1920s and 1930s, the garage was agent for various makes of automobiles, including: Buick, Dodge, Willys, Overland, Oldsmobile, DeSoto, Plymouth, and Pontiac. The following July 24, 1928 Stony Brook Garage receipt, via Pinterest, is for a Buick sold to John Fisher.

7/24/1928 Buick receipt from Stony Brook Garage (Pinterest)

The Stony Brook Garage is primarily remembered as a Pontiac Dealership. The garage focused on solely selling Pontiacs beginning in 1940. However during the 1930s, Pontiacs were sold, along with other makes; such as Oldsmobiles, Plymouths, and DeSotos. The first ad featuring the Stony Brook Garage selling Pontiacs appeared in 1931.

PONTIAC Dealers ad in The Gazette and Daily of July 22, 1931. This Pontiac costs $782 delivered … one of the listed dealers is Stony Brook Garage, Stony Brook, York Route 7

In 1947, the business incorporated as Stony Brook Garage, Inc. Stuart’s son, Stuart Strickler, Jr., become more involved with the business. The business also operated a Good Will Used Cars lot at 3611 East Market Street.

The following circa 1940s or 50s photo of Stony Brook Garage is from the Charles Ness Service Station Collection at York County History Center. At that time, the garage is selling Atlantic gasoline. The road at the extreme left side of the photo is Pleasant Acres Road.

Stony Brook Garage at 3701 East Market Street in Stony Brook, Springettsbury Township– the road at extreme left is Pleasant Acres Road (ca 1940s or 50s Photo from Charles Ness Service Station Collection at York County History Center)

The death of Stuart Strickler, Jr., in September of 1974, resulted in the decision by his father to close the garage in December of 1974. Beginning in January 1975, B. & B. Glass and Upholstery Company of Baltimore occupied the building at 3701 East Market Street under a lease-sales agreement. B. & B. purchased the building in 1981. The building is presently vacant.

3701 East Market Street in Stony Brook, Springettsbury Township. The right, front section is original 1921 Stony Brook Garage; with additions to left & rear, prior to closing that business in 1974 (2020 Google Street View)

Click on this LINK for a yorkblog.com Full View of the photos and illustrations in this post.

Links to selected Lincoln Highway posts include:

Lincoln Highway Garage in Wrightsville
Lincoln Highway Garage in Hallam
The Highway Bridge Service Station on the Lincoln Highway
Lincoln Highway Garage on EAST Market Street in York
Lincoln Highway Garage on WEST Market Street in York
Lincoln Highway Centennial Auto Tour at Haines Shoe House
York was in danger of losing the Lincoln Highway during 1914
ROAD OF REMEMBRANCE Memorial in Paradise Township
Melvin’s Drive-In, Lincoln Highway Ice Cream Bar

Reading the Headlines: A Quick Index to All YorksPast Posts