Part of the USA Today Network

Hayshire Hardware store, located at 2805 N. George Street, Manchester Township, York County, PA. (Circa 1955 photo submitted by Rob Leiphart)

Hayshire and their neighborhood Hardware Store

Before Lowe’s and Home Depot, many neighborhood Hardware Stores dotted the landscape of York County. Rob Leiphart shared a photo and some insight about one such store, Hayshire Hardware; named after, and located within, a suburban development in Manchester Township.

Before Rob’s parents married, his mother, Ruth, worked at Hayshire Hardware and at a prior business in that same building. Seventy years later that building still stands at 2805 North George Street.

Rob Leiphart e-mailed: “The Hayshire Hardware business moved into a building vacated by a grocery store. Mom worked at the grocery store. It was her first steady job away from the farm. In her third year most of the remaining regular customers defected to chain stores. The grocery store closed. The same year, Mom returned to the same building as one of the initial employees at the hardware store. Her section of the store sold Sunbeam appliances, cooking ware, and toys.”

Rob inquired if I could uncover the name of the grocery store. He also observed the grocery/hardware building is the same build type as the Lincoln Highway Garage and wondered if it started out as a service station.

Within Newspapers.com, notices were found, which indicate the grocery story, at 2805 North George Street, was Cousler’s Food Market. It was in business from April of 1951, and possibly earlier, until October of 1955.

Using 1947 and 1957 historic aerial photos, the building at 2805 North George Street was built sometime between those years. Therefore for the building to start out as a service station, it would have to be built after October 20, 1947. Early country grocery stores occasionally sold gasoline, so it is possible the building functioned as a service station; although unlikely in this case.

Aerial photos of the Hayshire vicinity in Manchester Township, York County, Pa. (Left side is 2020 Google aerial photo, and right side is Oct. 20, 1947 historic aerial photo, with October 9, 1957 historic aerial Insert; Annotated by S.H. Smith 2021)

Hayshire Hardware opens for business at 2805 N. George St.; per their following half-page ad in The Gazette & Daily of December 5, 1955. The ad notes they handle: Hardware, Fireplace Fixtures, Tools (Stanley, Disston and Tru-Temper), Paint (Valspar Paint, Varnish and Enamels), Brassware (Plaques, Planters, etc.), Toys, Housewares (Revere, Pyrex and Wearever), and Appliances (Sunbeam, Shick and Dormeyer). In the Spring and Summer, the store featured gardening supplies; with a tag line: “Supplies for Suburban Living.”

Hayshire Hardware is open for business at 2805 N. George St.; per their half-page ad in The Gazette & Daily of Dec. 5, 1955

The Hayshire area was a development planned by Attorney George Hay Kain, Jr. His ads advertised: “You’ll like Hayshire. Yorks First Complete Community; Church, School, Homes and Stores.” The Homes were advertised as “More Than 2,000 Sq. Ft., comfortable for Living, Priced at only $13,500.” The initial section of Hayshire contained 350-lots; with the initial homes constructed in 1956.

The Hayshire Drive loop encompasses the entrance to the housing development from North George Street. The northwest section of Hayshire Drive was reserved for Stores; i.e. where Hayshire Hardware was located. The southwest section of the Drive was reserved for a Church. And a School was planned for the east side of Hayshire Drive.

In 1955, the Central School District Board of Education took up the offer by George Hay Kain, Jr. of 11-acres for the new school. In December of 1955, the bids to build the 12-room Hayshire School were opened; $358,844 was the construction cost. The school opened in the Fall of 1957; and since then, it has been expanded several times.

In 1955, George Hay Kain, Jr. donated 3-acres to the Board of National Missions of the Reformed Church, for constructing a new church. It was intended for a newly formed congregation; which, during their initial years, conducted worship services in Alert Fire Company Hall in Emigsville. Groundbreaking for construction of the church on the Hayshire site began in March of 1959. The Hayshire United Church of Christ was occupied for the initial worship services in November of 1959.

Perhaps the oldest building, still standing, within Hayshire, once housed Hayshire Hardware at 2805 N. George Street. I wonder how many businesses operated in that building over the past 70-years? Rob Leiphart thought it was an ice cream shop, at one time. That building presently is occupied by York Dance Expressions.

York Dance Expressions is present occupant in building at 2805 N. George St. (Photo: Google Streetview, October 2019)

Click on this LINK for a yorkblog.com Full View of the photos and illustrations in this post.

Link to related posts:

Reminiscences of Walking to North Hills School

Satterthwaite artwork of unique store near Yorkana

Emig Mansion and the Underpass relic.

J. Horace Rudy stained glass, of Emigsville’s Howard Emig, in Offices of the H. J. Heinz Company

Reading the Headlines: A Quick Index to All YorksPast Posts