
To make way for a Holiday Inn at 2600 East Market Street, on Wednesday morning April 15, 1964, the ranch house of Eddie Herr is shown moving onto the Lincoln Highway, then headed east to Yorkshire and was placed on a new foundation at 3233 Eastern Blvd. (The Gazette and Daily, April 16, 1964, Pg. 47)
Answering questions about Eddie Herr
Bob Kessler shared some details about his grandparents that prompted interesting questions about Eddie Herr, primarily related to his 2600 East Market Street property in Springettsbury Township. Eddie Herr called that 4-acre property, containing his suburban ranch home, with multiple businesses and stables, ‘Belly Acres.’
Quoting a section of Bob Kessler’s initial e-mail: “Following my grandpa’s passing, my mom doled out some stories that I found fascinating. Grandpa and grandma met for the first time, while watching Eddie Herr’s house rolling down East Market Street, and married exactly one year latter. So I know the house moved on April 15, 1964. Any photos of the move? Did you know it was moved to a lot intended for a Mormon church? In one of your YouTube lectures, you talked about Eddie Herr’s beer business, grandpa’s father drove a beer truck, maybe for Eddie Herr?”
Bob Kessler pinpointed the day of the move exactly, with a photo of the move appearing in The Gazette and Daily of April 16, 1964. The caption noted the move started yesterday at about 10:15 a.m. and was completed by mid-afternoon. Francis I. Gerrick, of Littlestown, did the moving.
Who is Eddie Herr
This post focuses on Eddie Herr, Jr., who lived until 1975. His dad, Eddie Herr, Sr. died in 1947. It was Eddie Herr, Sr. who went into the insurance business in York during 1915. His former three-story office building, at 34-36 North George Street, is still topped in big letters: “EDDIE HERR BUILDING.”
Eddie Herr, Jr. worked for his dad for a while, however eventually branched out into multiple other businesses. All the while, an ardent interest in horses was ever present. Eddie built a suburban ranch house along Lincoln Highway East in 1937. On that property he built a horse stable compound and track where he trained trotter and racehorses. And other businesses evolved along the way.
‘Belly Acres’ is an interesting 4-acre property along the Lincoln Highway, which was never sold by Eddie Herr. The land was leased out for 99-years via a Trust set up for his descendants. A Holiday Inn opened on the property late in 1964; it is now a Quality Inn & Suites.
The following 2016 photo shows the 3233 Eastern Boulevard front of the former Eddie Herr ranch house, once located at 2600 East Market Street. The left side, facing west, is the side next to the truck in the April 15, 1964 house-moving photo.

Mormon Church site in Yorkshire
I had never heard Bob Kessler’s assertion that the 3233 Eastern Boulevard lot was intended for a Mormon church. However, deed searches and a newspaper articles proved he is correct.
The Eastern States Mission of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints purchased lots 29 and 30, within the Plan of Yorkshire, during 1954 (per deeds 39Z-383 & 40A-7). And quoting from a December 3, 1954 Gazette and Daily article: “York Mormons have purchased a piece of property at the northwest corner of Edgewood road and Eastern boulevard, Springettsbury township, for eventual construction of a church. There are no immediate plans for building. York area Mormons worship each Sunday at 10 a.m. at the YMCA. President of the York branch, which has about 60 members is Stewart Strayer, 491 West King Street.”
The church was never built on the 0.54-acre lot in Yorkshire, because the membership was growing so fast, that it was decided to purchase a larger lot in 1960; which is the present 2.62-acre lot at 2100 Hollywood Drive. The church on that site opened in 1963, with a congregation of 190.
The church sold the combined Yorkshire lots 29 and 30, through go-between Horace E. Smith, to allow placement of the Eddie Herr ranch house at 3233 Eastern Boulevard. Dr. Ronald L. Klimes, M.D. conducted a medical practice in the building from 1965 to 1997. Thereafter it has been used as a dental office, with Dr. Jeffrey L. Goodis, D.M.D. being the first one in the Yorkshire Dental Center.
Eddie Herr’s Beer Business
In 1949, Eddie Herr was granted the exclusive York County distributorship for Gunther’s Premium Dry Beer, brewed by the Gunther Brewing Company in Baltimore, Maryland. Two of his stables were converted into beer warehouses. Herr had a fleet of delivery trucks, which were radio equipped. Via phoned in orders, they speedily delivered Gunther Beer to homes, taverns and restaurants.

In 1956, Herr constructed a new beer distributor office and sales building, as he began handling additional brands. The 56-feet by 30-feet one-story brick and frame structure could provide beverages from cold storage and was air-conditioned. The drive through carport was set up to rapidly dispense orders to drive-through customers.
The following photo shows Eddie Herr’s new beer distributor sales building prior to the May 1956 opening. It was the only Eddie Herr building repurposed at its original location upon the 1964 construction of the Holiday Inn at 2600 East Market Street.

When repurposed the drive-through carport was walled-in for additional rental space. The motel rented that commercial building, with address 2550 East Market Street, to businesses such as: Insurance Company representatives, Fashion and Gift shops, Consignment shops, Quick printing shops, Barber shops, Beauty salons, a Car rental office, and a Sandwich shop.
The barbers I regularly went to moved to the 2550 East Market Street building in 1992. Ray’s Barber Shop was forced to move when their section of the York County Shopping Center was demolished during the reconfiguration to the York Marketplace. The three barbers, Ray Wilson, Ellis Myers, and Paul Mummert, moved into the former carport area of the Eddie Herr building. Coming full circle, they had a nice glass container filled with hard candies and lollypops on the counter, a container which Eddie Herr had gifted them when the Barber Shop opening in the York County Shopping Center during 1955.

Click on this LINK for a yorkblog.com Full View of the photos and illustrations in this post.
Links to related posts:
Eddie Herr’s Belly Acres and business of bussing horses
Moving Buildings to Accommodate I-83
Neat Photo of House on the Move
Earliest plans for Yorkshire on the Lincoln Highway
Reading the Headlines: A Quick Index to All YorksPast Posts