Wandering in York County

Part of the USA Today Network

Tom Melhorn and his cohort of local history students at Dallastown Area High School. Tom Melhorn Photo.

Local Civil War history flourishes at Dallastown Area High School

When did you realize you loved learning about local history? I had three moments where I became aware of my fascination of York County.

  1. Seeing my great-great-grandfather’s name, Charles E. Reisinger, as a juror for the 1929 Hex Murder trial.
  2. Learning that Quakers have been meeting at the York Friends Meeting House since 1766. The fact that I could witness their worship first-hand never made history feel so alive.
  3. And, my time as a student in Tom Melhorn’s Local History class at Dallastown Area High School.

Since I graduated from Dallastown in 2008, Melhorn has continued teaching local history. His 0.5 credit course is offered all three trimesters. That means close to 75 students took the course during the 2018-2019 school year.

Melhorn’s curriculum spans from the time of the Iroquois Confederacy to present day, incorporating information about the Susquehannocks, Hex Hollow murder, Articles of Confederation, William Goodridge, and Special Olympians such as Loretta Claiborne. Furthermore, Melhorn incorporates our industrial history including the manufacturing of cars, cigars, and war tanks. It’s important to note that York’s history is very local but also ties into national level events.

As a fellow Social Studies teacher, I wondered what awesome projects Melhorn created. This came not only from sheer curiosity, but also so I could incorporate his great ideas into my own curriculum (My teacher readers know – we beg, borrow, and steal as many cool lesson ideas we can!) So I emailed him to see what he was up to in his local history class nowadays. 

Melhorn’s favorite project was the Civil War website.

The website header for the local history project for Melhorn’s class at Dallastown Area High School.

Dallastown’s local Civil War history website

Individually and in groups, students researched the 30th, 41st, 45th, 76th, 87th, and 130th regiments of Pennsylvania as well as York natives, Union Gen. William Franklin and Confederate Gen. Johnson Kelly Duncan. 

A snapshot of a website created by Tom Melhorn’s students in his local history class.

Most importantly, the students conducted their own difficult research. “The material was not simply sitting in a book or website waiting for them,” Melhorn told me during an interview. Often, teachers pull articles, websites, or books for their students to peruse. But, when you can get a student to dig deep, fostering their curiosity, that’s when life-long learners are born.

They checked the regimental rolls, detailed battlefield maps, and the history of a few battles to try to find more specific  details. Melhorn said, “Sure, we looked at some books and sites on the regiments, but many regiments do not have a book or site dedicated to them.  I posed the project in a way that… if a site doesn’t exist, then let’s make one.”

The website creation incorporated 21st-century skills that would help them in our technocentric world.

If you want to see the work-in-progress website for yourself, click HERE.

What did the students say about project?

Shaelyn Smith believes “local history illuminates York County’s rich history. It gives students a sense of pride to be from York County.”  

“This class was one of the best classes I have had,” Charles Melbourne thinks. “I know a lot more about where I live now than I ever did in the past.”

Jack Shuchart, local history student, stands in front of Dallastown Area High School. Tom Melhorn Photo.

Brynn Long thinks in two successive sentences, “I enjoyed that we got to learn about how involved York was with being willing to fight in war and raising money for wars.  The class teaches you about all of the history and makes it easier to appreciate York.”

“I love to learn about the importance of where I live,” says Cooper Webber. “It is so cool to know about what York has done for our country!”

Finally, Jack Shuchart said, “From all of that, we are still able to call York County home.”

There are some common themes here. But the most important, I believe, is pride and appreciation. Recognizing the significance of where we live – seeing how special it is – will germinate the seeds of local history interest in the next generation.

While Melhorn doesn’t think anyone in the room turned into the next York-based Civil War historian Scott Mingus, the students did create something to expose a part of York’s history that has fallen through the cracks.

Local history students featured from left to right – Brynn Long, Cooper Webber, My’Lek Canty, Charles Melbourne, and Dalton Burke. Tom Melhorn Photo.

York’s involvement in the Civil War

A segment of the Civil War website created by the students in Tom Melhorn’s local history class.

Here is what Melhorn believes are the major takeaways of York’s Civil War history: “A couple of years ago, I wanted to alter the Local History class and start to teach it from a thematic perspective.  What I kept on coming across was how York soldiers and York County people were involved in every major war and nearly every major battle. Even the people that couldn’t fight gave tons of money to the government to support the war by buying victory bonds (in World War I and II) or by taking pride in their work making wartime material for companies involved in the York Plan.”

Melhorn mentions several of York’s involvements in war such as the Revolutionary War when York soldiers marched 414 miles to Boston to support our allies after the Battle of Bunker Hill.  Additionally, he points out, York also fought in the Battle of Fort Washington in New York, in Trenton, Princeton, and nearly every major Revolutionary War Battle. 

Melhorn sums it up well, “We signed up, we fought, we sacrificed, and leaders praised us for our commitment and our skill.  We were there for our country always, and we deserve to be proud of that. I want the students to leave the class with a sincere pride in their home, and this builds upon that goal. It’s York County history,” Melhorn states, “the focus should be on appreciation, not stress.”

Why offer courses such as local history?

Every year, I receive notes from three to four students that say something along the lines of, “Before this class, I HATED history. You made it fun and now social studies is one of my favorite subjects!” Comments like this light up my world. I was able to inspire young adults half my age to appreciate how we, as a human race, got to where we are now. Giving students the option to learn specific lessons about specific places they can visit removes the compartmentalized blinders that classrooms are notorious for both physically and metaphorically constructing. 

Just like my school, Dallastown values student choice in their schedules, Melhorn told me. The point is to offer options so students want to learn the content taught in the course. As most teachers know, when students can exercise the power of choice, a new sense of ownership emerges unparallel to an assigned topic chosen by the teacher.

After Mr. Melhorn’s class, I couldn’t help but want to know more about York’s history. Since then, I’ve continued to foster my love of history but I have his class to thank for planting that curiosity seed during my days at Dallastown.

Keep studying and sharing history!

The next generation of local historians! Tom Melhorn Photo.

4 comments on “Local Civil War history flourishes at Dallastown Area High School

  1. It is so refreshing to hear a out this side of the Civil War
    I grew up on York country andmy husband’s military career took us South. They are stoll angry that the North won and insist on marching around their monuments every Sunday with their Confederate flags even though it hurts so many people who associate that flag with violent racism. I now live in Va which is some better.

  2. On behalf of the Company C, 87th PVI reenactors unit. We would like to invite your group to our next local Living History event at the Gettysburg Heritage Museum, on June 22nd and 23. 2019

    We look forward to hearing from you.

    Corporal Don Warner, 87th PVI, Company C

    1. Thanks for the invite! Unfortunately, I will be in Baltimore that weekend but I’ll send this along to Tom Melhorn.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.